Virginia Tech Study: Resistance Training Outperforms Endurance for Blood Sugar
Virginia Tech scientists at the Fralin Biomedical Research Institute have conducted a study indicating that resistance training surpasses endurance exercise in improving insulin sensitivity, particularly in models of obesity and Type 2 diabetes. Published on October 30 in the Journal of Sport and Health Science, the research involved a comparison of the effects of endurance and resistance exercise using mice fed a high-fat diet, a common model for studying obesity and diabetes.
Led by exercise medicine researcher Zhen Yan, the study found that both running and weightlifting contributed to the body's ability to clear excess sugar from the bloodstream. However, resistance training proved to be more effective in reducing both subcutaneous and visceral fat, enhancing glucose tolerance, and decreasing insulin resistance—key factors in diabetes prevention and management.
"We all want to live a long, healthy life," Yan stated, emphasizing the known benefits of regular exercise. While both types of exercise are beneficial for metabolic function, the study aimed to provide a direct comparison, which had been lacking in previous research.
To achieve this, the researchers developed a novel mouse model of weightlifting. In this model, mice were placed in specially designed cages where they could access food by lifting a hinged, weighted lid, mimicking the muscle contractions involved in resistance training. The resistance load was gradually increased, simulating progressive strength training. Mice in the endurance group had open access to a running wheel, a standard model for aerobic exercise, while control groups included sedentary mice on either a normal or high-fat diet.
Over an eight-week period, the team monitored various health metrics, including weight gain, body composition, fat distribution, exercise capacity, and blood sugar regulation. They also analyzed skeletal muscle tissue to investigate insulin signaling at the molecular level.
The findings revealed that both running and weightlifting reduced abdominal and subcutaneous fat while improving blood glucose maintenance through enhanced insulin signaling in skeletal muscle. Notably, weightlifting was found to provide superior health benefits compared to running.
Given the rising public health challenges associated with diabetes and obesity, the study's findings underscore the importance of incorporating both endurance and resistance exercise into fitness regimens. Yan noted that for individuals unable to engage in endurance exercises for various reasons, weight training offers comparable, if not superior, anti-diabetes benefits.
Additionally, the research observed changes in skeletal muscle signaling pathways that could inform future drug therapies for Type 2 diabetes. The benefits of resistance training were not solely attributed to changes in muscle mass or exercise performance, suggesting that unique metabolic mechanisms are involved.
Yan concluded that while drug interventions like GLP-1 agonists can aid in diabetes management, they do not replace the comprehensive benefits of a balanced exercise program. The study advocates for a combination of both endurance and resistance training to maximize health benefits.
This research was supported by grants from the National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases of the National Institutes of Health and the Red Gates Foundation. The original study can be accessed at doi.org/10.1016/j.jshs.2025.101100.




