Health Researchers Advocate for Permanent Standard Time to Protect Sleep and Mental Health
Canadian health researchers are urging Canada to adopt permanent standard time instead of permanent daylight saving time, especially as provinces consider eliminating the twice-yearly clock change. Their analysis warns that darker winter mornings could have detrimental effects on sleep and mental health. The study, led by Professor Raymond Lam from the University of British Columbia, emphasizes that while ending the clock change solves one issue, it raises another: which time should be maintained year-round? According to Lam, the health evidence supports standard time, as morning light is crucial for regulating our body clocks, sleep patterns, and overall mood.
Several Canadian jurisdictions, including Yukon and British Columbia, have already moved towards permanent daylight saving time, while the United States House of Representatives has passed a bill to establish permanent daylight saving time nationwide, pending Senate approval. However, the researchers argue that the accumulated evidence favors permanent standard time, which aligns more closely with human circadian biology. This distinction is particularly significant during winter months when natural light is scarce.
For instance, under permanent daylight saving time, sunrise in cities like Toronto would occur as late as 8:51 a.m. in winter, compared to 7:51 a.m. under standard time. This shift could result in individuals commuting to work or school before sunrise, potentially impacting their sleep, mood, learning, and productivity, especially for those who already struggle with sleep issues or have early schedules. Professor Ralph Mistlberger from Simon Fraser University notes that our biological clocks require morning light to remain synchronized with the 24-hour day, and delaying this light could exacerbate sleep disruptions.
The analysis also raises concerns about seasonal affective disorder (SAD), which affects 1-3% of Canadians, with up to 15% experiencing milder seasonal mood changes. Symptoms of SAD, including poor sleep and low energy, are particularly pronounced during winter. Bright light therapy is a recognized treatment for SAD, and by delaying access to natural morning light, permanent daylight saving time could hinder this important circadian signal.
While the researchers acknowledge that permanent standard time has its drawbacks, such as earlier summer sunrises that may disturb those who wake early, they recommend practical solutions like blackout curtains and public education on sleep health to mitigate these effects. In contrast, the broader implications of permanent daylight saving time would necessitate extensive measures to counteract the consequences of darker winter mornings, including improved street lighting, flexible work schedules, and later school start times.
The researchers advocate for governments to monitor the effects of whichever time system is adopted, focusing on metrics such as school absenteeism, mental health, sleep issues, and workplace injuries. They emphasize the need for data analysis across various demographics to ensure that the impacts are equitably understood. Dr. Patrick Baylis, co-author of the study, points out that while the appeal of permanent daylight saving time is clear—more light in the evenings—this must be balanced against evidence linking it to reduced sleep and lower productivity. The findings of this study are published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal, highlighting the need for informed policy decisions regarding time changes in Canada.




