Intermittent Fasting: A Personal Journey and Its Effects on Women's Health
Ava Durgin reflects on her two-year journey with intermittent fasting (IF), a popular dietary approach that focuses on when to eat rather than what to eat. Initially, she embraced the idea of skipping breakfast, believing it to be a productivity hack that would lead to weight loss and improved health. Indeed, she did lose weight and felt as though she had discovered a secret to success. However, this experience took a toll on her overall well-being. Durgin experienced significant energy loss, a decline in her motivation to exercise, and disruptions to her menstrual cycle.
Intermittent fasting typically involves restricting eating to a specific window of time, often the 16:8 method, where individuals fast for 16 hours and consume food within an 8-hour period. During fasting, the body is thought to switch from burning glucose to utilizing stored fat, which can support metabolic health and weight management. However, Durgin points out that much of the research surrounding IF has been conducted primarily on men or mixed groups without specific analysis by sex, which is crucial given the hormonal differences between men and women.
Women's bodies rely on a delicate balance of hormones, including estrogen and progesterone, which are essential for maintaining a regular menstrual cycle. These hormones can be significantly affected by stress, and prolonged fasting, particularly when combined with intense exercise, can signal the body to respond to stress. This response is mediated by the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, which regulates cortisol levels. While cortisol plays a vital role in energy mobilization, consistently high levels can suppress reproductive hormones, leading to irregular periods or even amenorrhea in some women.
Durgin's experience illustrates this point; she noticed changes in her menstrual cycle as she continued her fasting regimen. She also found that women might experience more pronounced blood sugar fluctuations and cortisol responses to fasting compared to men, which can complicate the effects of intermittent fasting for active women or those under stress.
Despite the initial benefits she perceived, Durgin ultimately recognized that her fasting routine was unsustainable and detrimental to her health. After several months without her period and a candid discussion with her doctor, she decided to make a significant change: she began eating breakfast. Initially, this felt strange, as she had adhered to her fasting routine for so long. However, she soon found joy in nourishing her body with meals in the morning. Her energy levels improved, her menstrual cycle returned, and she felt more balanced overall.
Now, Durgin emphasizes the importance of starting the day with a nutritious breakfast, which she believes is essential for maintaining energy and hormonal balance. She recommends incorporating protein, healthy fats, and quality carbohydrates into breakfast to support overall well-being. For her, this has included Greek yogurt with fruits and homemade granola or savory options like eggs and vegetables.
Durgin concludes that while intermittent fasting may work for some individuals, particularly those who are not under stress or in their peak reproductive years, it is not a one-size-fits-all solution. She encourages others to listen to their bodies and prioritize nourishment, especially in the context of their unique health needs. This personal account serves as a reminder that dietary practices should be tailored to individual circumstances, particularly for women, who may experience different physiological responses to fasting and nutrition.




