Seattle City Council Passes Landmark Legislation Against Surveillance Pricing in Groceries
In a significant move towards consumer protection, the Seattle City Council has passed the Fair Pricing and Transparency Act (CB 121267), aimed at banning the controversial practice of surveillance pricing in grocery sales. If signed into law by Mayor Wilson, Seattle will become the first city in the United States to implement such a prohibition. The legislation, which received backing from Consumer Reports, seeks to prevent the use of personal data—such as web browsing history, real-time location, income inferences, and health conditions—to manipulate grocery prices for consumers.
The bill allows for a variety of discounting practices while mandating greater transparency regarding discounts and imposing limitations on consumer profiling. Grace Gedye, a senior policy analyst at Consumer Reports, emphasized the importance of this legislation, stating, "Nobody should pay more for basic necessities because a data broker is quietly collecting information about what they’re searching for online, what they hover over, what their income is, or where they go." She commended the City Council for making Seattle a leader in protecting shoppers from unfair pricing tactics.
The legislation comes in response to growing concerns about how companies use consumer data to set prices. Other states, including Maryland, Connecticut, and New Jersey, have already enacted similar laws to curb surveillance pricing practices. In a related investigation, Consumer Reports found that Kroger was collecting extensive data profiles on individual shoppers, which included sensitive information such as income and family size. This raised alarms about the potential for price discrimination based on personal data.
Further investigations by Consumer Reports into pricing tactics used by Instacart revealed significant price discrepancies for identical products, with differences reaching up to 23% for some items. This could potentially cost families over $1,200 annually at checkout. Instacart has since announced it will discontinue practices that resulted in price differences among shoppers but will still allow grocery retailers to test various promotions.
Consumer Reports has also scrutinized the pricing strategies of ride-hailing companies like Uber and Lyft, which often charge different customers varying amounts for similar rides, raising further questions about fairness in pricing across different sectors. The passage of the Fair Pricing and Transparency Act in Seattle marks a pivotal step in addressing these issues in grocery pricing, aiming to ensure that consumers are treated fairly and transparently in their shopping experiences.




