Study Reveals Many Adults Fail to Meet Flavanol Intake Recommendations for Heart Health
A study published in the journal Food & Function has revealed that fewer than one in four adults who adhere to standard dietary guidelines for fruit and vegetable consumption manage to consume the recommended 500 milligrams of flavanols each day. This finding suggests that following current nutritional advice may not be sufficient to ensure adequate intake of these beneficial plant compounds, which are associated with cardiovascular health improvements.
The 500-milligram target derives from the Cocoa Supplement and Multivitamin Outcomes Study (COSMOS), a clinical trial that demonstrated a 27 percent reduction in cardiovascular-related deaths among participants who took a cocoa extract supplement containing this amount of flavanols daily. The research also analyzed data from the U.K.-based EPIC-Norfolk cohort, where it was found that higher overall produce intake did not necessarily correlate with meeting the flavanol threshold, indicating that the types of fruits and vegetables consumed may be more critical than the total quantity.
Flavanols, a subgroup of flavonoids, are naturally occurring compounds found in foods such as tea, cocoa, apples, and berries. Although not classified as essential nutrients, studies have linked flavanols to improved blood vessel function, reduced inflammation, and protection against oxidative damage. The most studied flavanols include catechins and epicatechin, with the latter being particularly abundant in cocoa and a focal point of cardiovascular research.
Extensive research has associated flavanol consumption with lower blood pressure and a reduced risk of heart disease. A meta-analysis involving over 5,200 adults indicated that flavanol-rich foods, including dark chocolate and tea, can lower blood pressure comparably to some medications. Historical accounts also highlight the significance of cocoa; for instance, the Aztec Emperor Montezuma referred to it as a "divine drink" that enhances endurance.
The study analyzed data from two large cohorts: the COSMOS trial in the U.S. and the EPIC-Norfolk study in the U.K., encompassing over 30,000 adults. Instead of relying on self-reported dietary intake, the researchers employed validated biological markers to measure flavanol consumption, thereby minimizing potential reporting errors. The study's thresholds for high flavanol intake were intentionally set to overestimate compliance, suggesting that the actual percentage of individuals meeting the target may be even lower.
In the COSMOS cohort, participants with better overall diet quality consumed slightly more flavanols, but only a modest difference was observed. Less than 25 percent of those who met the dietary guidelines for fruit and vegetable intake reached the estimated flavanol intake of 500 milligrams per day. Conversely, in the EPIC-Norfolk cohort, those adhering most closely to U.K. dietary guidelines had lower odds of reaching the flavanol threshold, indicating that simply consuming more produce does not guarantee higher flavanol intake if the selected foods are low in these compounds.
The researchers concluded that existing dietary guidelines may not adequately ensure sufficient flavanol intake and emphasized the need for specific dietary targets for these beneficial compounds. One study author noted, "The main result of our research is that it is important to choose flavanol-rich foods." The findings underscore a disconnect between general nutritional recommendations and the intake of specific bioactive compounds linked to heart health.
The study does have limitations. The COSMOS trial utilized a cocoa extract supplement rather than dietary flavanols, and the current analysis treats flavanols as a broad category. Different dietary sources may exhibit varying bioavailability, and the supplement form may not behave identically to flavanols derived from whole foods. Additionally, two authors of the study are affiliated with Mars, Incorporated, which funded the COSMOS trial, raising potential concerns about conflicts of interest.
Despite these funding ties, the researchers assert that the results are consistent across two independent, peer-reviewed cohorts. The study's findings have been presented at scientific conferences and suggest that dietary guidance emphasizing flavanol-rich choices could have significant public health implications.
Rich sources of flavanols include tea, apples (with skin), berries, unsweetened cocoa, and legumes such as pinto and kidney beans. Flavanols from grapes, berries, and cocoa have been studied for their anti-obesity properties and cardiovascular benefits. Minimally processed dark chocolate and black tea are noted as superior sources due to their higher flavanol content, while low-flavanol produce like iceberg lettuce contributes minimally, highlighting the importance of food selection over sheer quantity.
As one study author remarked, "The key is not just eating more produce, but choosing the right ones." By prioritizing flavanol-rich foods, consumers can potentially improve their flavanol intake. Suggestions for increasing flavanol consumption include incorporating a cup of green or black tea, a handful of berries, an apple, or a serving of unsweetened cocoa into daily diets.




