Housing Lottery Results Show Lower Rates of Severe Obesity and Diabetes
Between 1994 and 1998, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development conducted a significant study called Moving to Opportunity, which aimed to assess the effects of relocating families from high-poverty neighborhoods to areas with lower poverty rates. This initiative randomly assigned 4,498 families from public housing in cities like Baltimore, Boston, Chicago, Los Angeles, and New York to different groups. One group received a housing voucher that could only be used in neighborhoods where fewer than 10 percent of residents were below the poverty line, along with counseling to assist with the move. Another group received a standard voucher with no restrictions, while a control group received no vouchers at all.
Twelve years after the randomization, researchers conducted health assessments on participants, measuring body mass index (BMI) and blood sugar levels. The results were striking: women who had moved to low-poverty neighborhoods showed a 4.61 percentage point reduction in the prevalence of severe obesity (BMI of 35 or more) and a 4.31 percentage point reduction in diabetes rates, compared to the control group. In relative terms, these reductions represented significant decreases of 13.0 percent for severe obesity and 21.6 percent for diabetes. However, the rates of ordinary obesity (BMI of 30 or more) did not show any significant change among the participants who moved.
Interestingly, the group with unrestricted vouchers did not demonstrate any significant health improvements compared to the control group, suggesting that the act of moving to a less impoverished area, rather than just moving itself, may have played a crucial role in the observed health benefits. The study's authors noted that fewer than half of the families offered the low-poverty voucher actually utilized it, and the control group also experienced a decrease in neighborhood poverty over time, complicating the interpretation of the results.
Despite these findings, the authors cautioned against overgeneralizing the results. They highlighted that the sample predominantly included families headed by black or Hispanic women with children, which may not represent other demographic groups. Additionally, the study could not definitively establish the mechanisms behind the observed health improvements, as access to healthcare remained constant across groups.
In a related analysis, researchers Kristen Cooksey-Stowers and colleagues examined the relationship between food environments and obesity across U.S. counties. Their findings indicated that food deserts—areas lacking access to supermarkets—did not significantly correlate with obesity rates. Instead, the presence of fast food outlets (termed food swamps) was found to have a more substantial impact on obesity, particularly in areas where residents had limited transportation options.
These studies collectively suggest that while neighborhood conditions can influence health outcomes, the relationship is complex and influenced by various factors, including access to healthy food options and the socioeconomic context of the area. They underscore the importance of considering both the physical environment and individual circumstances when addressing public health issues related to obesity and diabetes.




