Global Survey Reveals Dietary Guidelines Underrepresent Plant-Based Foods
A new study published in the peer-reviewed journal Current Developments in Nutrition indicates that although a majority of health and nutrition professionals consult their national dietary guidelines regularly, less than half consider them effective for guiding individuals towards healthier and more sustainable dietary choices. The research, conducted by ProVeg International in collaboration with the University of Göttingen, surveyed practitioners about the challenges they encounter when applying food-based dietary guidelines (FBDGs). The findings reveal that while 80.5% of respondents utilize their national guidelines, 57.6% rated them as only 'somewhat' or 'slightly' helpful in promoting healthy and sustainable food options.
The study highlights that over 100 countries have published FBDGs, which collectively cover approximately 90% of the global population and influence public health messaging, education, and food assistance programs. However, respondents pointed out significant shortcomings in these guidelines, particularly regarding the underrepresentation of pulses (62.7%), plant-based milk alternatives (47.5%), and nuts and seeds (42.4%). Transparency in the development of these guidelines was deemed crucial for their acceptance by 99.1% of participants, and affordability emerged as a pressing concern, with calls for clearer guidance on maintaining a healthy diet on a limited budget.
Anna-Lena Klapp, Head of Research at ProVeg International and the lead author of the study, emphasized the potential of dietary guidelines to foster healthier and more sustainable food systems. However, she noted that these guidelines must be applicable in real-world scenarios. The professionals surveyed expressed a need for guidelines that better represent plant-based foods, address affordability, and acknowledge cultural diversity in dietary practices.
Furthermore, the survey revealed that many respondents believe the responsibility for dietary change extends beyond individual consumers. Approximately 65.3% supported initiatives such as tax relief or subsidies to reduce the cost of healthy and sustainable food, identifying retailers, restaurants, caterers, and food manufacturers as key players in facilitating healthier choices at the point of purchase.
These findings build on earlier research by Klapp, which analyzed national guidelines across 100 countries, revealing a general neglect of plant-based sources of protein, calcium, and iron. The divergence in national recommendations is notable, with the Dutch Health Council advocating that 60% of dietary protein should come from plant sources, while the 2025-2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans have faced criticism for omitting sustainability considerations entirely. Klapp concluded by stressing the need for supportive food environments to effectively implement these guidelines, advocating for coordinated action across the food system to make healthy and sustainable choices accessible to all.




