Research Reveals Smartwatches Overestimate Caloric Expenditure During Workouts
A study published in the journal PLOS One has raised concerns about the accuracy of calorie burn estimates provided by popular smartwatches. In this research, 58 adult participants completed a cycling workout while wearing four different smartwatch brands. The researchers compared the calorie estimates from these devices with clinical-grade measurements of actual energy expenditure.
The results revealed that all tested smartwatches displayed significant errors in their calorie burn estimates, typically ranging from 15% to 25% off the actual values. Among the devices, the Apple Watch performed the best, yet it still overestimated calorie burn by an average of 22 calories. The Samsung smartwatch was found to be off by approximately 57 calories, while the Garmin device overestimated by nearly 69 calories on average. The Fitbit's performance was more variable; about 13% of its trials produced implausibly high readings that were subsequently excluded from the main analysis.
Additionally, the study found that the accuracy of calorie estimates tended to decrease as body fat increased across all four brands. This trend is particularly concerning for individuals who depend on these numbers for weight management. Lead author Jason Kostrna, an associate professor of kinesiology and exercise science at Florida International University, highlighted the potential implications of these inaccuracies. "You could be hundreds of calories off each week and easily end up in a calorie surplus when you think you're in a calorie deficit," he stated in a news release.
Kostrna advised users to approach the calorie burn figures provided by their smartwatches with caution. He suggested that individuals consider rounding down the estimates and focus more on heart rate, heart-rate zones, and personal trends over time rather than relying solely on the calorie figures. The study's authors plan to conduct further tests to assess the accuracy of smartwatch calorie estimates during strength training exercises, which may present different challenges.
This research underscores the importance of understanding the limitations of wearable technology in fitness and nutrition, especially as more individuals turn to these devices for health management.




