Smart City Technologies: Examining Their Uneven Impact on Health Equity
As cities increasingly integrate artificial intelligence, telemedicine, and connected health systems into their infrastructure, a critical question arises: do these advancements promote health equity? A recent review titled "Smart City Technologies and Health Equity: A Review of Urban Health Outcomes and Sustainable Development (2019–2026)" published in Sustainability by researchers Mehdi Rezaei, Seungok An, Ehsan Heidarzadeh, and Ladan Rokni, delves into this issue, examining the evidence surrounding digital health and smart urban systems. The findings reveal that while smart city technologies have the potential to enhance healthcare access for some underserved populations, their overall impact on health equity is inconsistent and heavily influenced by local socio-economic conditions. Factors such as digital divides, socio-economic disparities, fragmented governance, and limited institutional capacity often hinder the equitable distribution of technological benefits. The review underscores the importance of people-centered design, participatory governance, and inclusive digital infrastructure as key elements that can improve health outcomes. With projections indicating that over 68 percent of the global population will reside in urban areas by 2050, cities are becoming pivotal in addressing public health challenges and digital transformation. However, the review cautions that poor design choices in smart city initiatives can exacerbate existing inequalities rather than mitigate them. The authors analyzed literature published between November 2019 and May 2026, screening 357 records and including 22 studies in their qualitative synthesis. They found that while many smart city initiatives claim to improve access and efficiency, direct evidence of reduced health disparities among different social or demographic groups remains scarce. For instance, although remote patient monitoring and mobile telemedicine clinics have successfully reached geographically isolated populations, increased access does not always correlate with diminished disparities, as demonstrated by a telehealth HIV-prevention program that failed to eliminate racial inequities. The review challenges the assumption that the mere diffusion of technology leads to inclusion, suggesting instead that without targeted interventions, technology may reinforce existing social structures. Institutional barriers, such as governance issues, emerge as significant obstacles to achieving health equity, indicating that the challenge often lies more in governance than in technological innovation itself. Infrastructure is another critical factor; reliable broadband, affordable devices, and interoperable health systems are essential for equitable access to smart health solutions. In regions where these resources are unevenly distributed, benefits tend to concentrate in wealthier neighborhoods. Furthermore, digital literacy plays a crucial role in determining how effectively marginalized groups can utilize available services. The review highlights that even when digital platforms are accessible, factors like language barriers and unfamiliarity with technology can limit actual usage. Governance failures can exacerbate these challenges, as seen in instances where pilot projects lack robust evaluation or integration into public health systems. The authors argue that investment in smart health initiatives must go hand in hand with strengthening institutional capacity, regulatory frameworks, and community engagement to avoid creating isolated pockets of innovation that fail to address broader health equity issues. The ethical implications of digital health technologies are also significant, particularly concerning data privacy and algorithmic bias. The review emphasizes the need for participatory governance, involving communities and stakeholders in the design of smart health systems to ensure that diverse needs are met and that technology does not impose standardized solutions. This is especially pertinent for cities in the Global South, where rapid digitization presents both opportunities and risks for marginalized communities. The review advocates for a holistic approach that connects digital transformation, public health, and environmental sustainability, suggesting that investments in digital infrastructure should consider their distributional impact and potential to improve health outcomes for vulnerable populations. Ultimately, the authors conclude that the future of healthy smart cities will depend not on the sophistication of their technologies but on the ability of institutions to translate these innovations into widespread public value.




