Advocates Push for Permanent Cash Assistance Policies as COVID-19 Relief Funds Expire
As federal COVID-19 relief funds approach their expiration, advocates for guaranteed income are striving to institutionalize pandemic-era cash assistance programs into permanent government policy. The Economic Security Project (ESP) recently published a report titled "Right on Time: How Cash Helps Families Move Through Life’s Transitions," which argues for the necessity of "no-strings-attached" cash assistance. This push comes as city leaders across the United States face a financial cliff, with many mayors scrambling to sustain local cash-handout experiments that were funded by federal pandemic aid.
Under federal law, local governments must legally obligate their American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds by December 31, 2024, with most funds needing to be fully spent by December 31, 2026. For instance, Evanston, Illinois, recently announced an expansion of its guaranteed income program using the remaining ARPA funds before the spending deadline. This city is among more than 100 municipalities that have initiated universal basic income-style pilots since 2018, many of which relied on a combination of private donations and federal stimulus funds, which are now dwindling.
The report emphasizes that direct cash transfers are a "legitimate policy tool," supported by data from over 250 cash and guaranteed-income pilots across 40 states and the District of Columbia. The authors cite the COVID-19 pandemic as a prime example of effective large-scale cash transfers that reached households quickly and efficiently.
Rather than advocating for immediate universal cash handouts, the report suggests a more tactical approach: linking direct payments to significant life events. The authors argue that cash assistance is most beneficial during times of personal or financial hardship, such as having a child, experiencing housing instability, or reentering society after incarceration. They contend that cash is most effective when it fills short gaps, allowing individuals to make informed decisions rather than rushed ones.
This strategic approach could also help garner public support, as the report indicates that tying cash assistance to life transitions aligns with existing public understanding of social safety nets. The authors note that programs like Social Security are accepted because they are perceived as earned benefits, and similar logic could apply to cash assistance linked to verified life disruptions.
The broader campaign for direct payments includes organizations like Mayors for Guaranteed Income, led by former Stockton, California, Mayor Michael Tubbs, who has been a vocal advocate for using federal tax dollars to support income supplements for low-income Americans facing rising costs of living. As these pilot programs transition into permanent taxpayer-funded initiatives, ESP authors recommend that lawmakers integrate cash assistance into existing social safety net programs, such as Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) and child welfare budgets.
ESP also encourages local and state governments to establish dedicated revenue streams from local taxes to sustain these efforts, moving away from reliance on donor funding. Founded in 2016, ESP has united over 100 entrepreneurs, activists, researchers, and philanthropists advocating for direct cash payments as a means to enhance economic security for families across the nation. As the expiration of federal funds looms, the challenge remains to convert these pilot programs into enduring solutions that address food access and economic stability for vulnerable populations.




