New Research Suggests Dual Origins of Life on Earth and Early Metabolic Processes
Where and how did life first emerge on Earth? These fundamental questions are explored in new research from the Institute of Molecular Evolution at Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf (HHU). An international team of biologists has published findings in Science Advances that illuminate the chemical reaction networks utilized by the earliest cells to produce essential life ingredients and the energy sources that fueled these reactions. By tracing the origins of enzymes during the initial split between bacteria and archaea, the researchers present evidence that free-living cells may have originated independently on two occasions.
Approximately 4 billion years ago, Earth was a vastly different environment. If we could witness the formation of the earliest cells, we might observe two distinct types of primitive cellular life emerging: pioneer bacteria and pioneer archaea, each striving for existence outside hydrothermal vents. Natalia Mrnjavac, a biologist at the University of Düsseldorf and lead author of the study, emphasizes this distinct emergence.
The research team examined genomes, protein structures, and chemical reactions to delve into the early stages of microbial evolution, particularly the period preceding the existence of fully free-living cells. This comprehensive approach provided unprecedented insights into the evolution of metabolism, which originated from spontaneous reactions catalyzed by metals found in the Earth's crust.
Instead of focusing solely on specific aspects of early metabolism, the researchers analyzed a complete set of chemical reactions that cells utilized to manufacture key biological components, such as amino acids, RNA bases, and vitamins, from materials available on early Earth, including hydrogen gas, ammonia, and carbon dioxide. This extensive metabolic network comprises 420 chemical reactions, which are remarkably ancient and conserved across life, akin to the genetic code.
A surprising revelation from the study is that the enzymes responsible for these reactions do not exhibit the same degree of conservation between bacteria and archaea. The last universal common ancestor of all cells, known as LUCA, possessed enzymes for only about half of the metabolic reactions, while the other half relied on environmental metal catalysts. This suggests that early metabolism was significantly influenced by the surrounding environment, contrasting with modern cellular metabolism.
The researchers identified that metals occurring naturally in hydrothermal vents could replace many enzymes in metabolic processes. This hybrid approach of enzymatic and metal catalysis marks a crucial phase in the evolution of biological catalysis. The study reconstructed four stages of early biological catalysis, beginning with reactions driven solely by metals, followed by a collaborative phase involving both metals and enzymes, and eventually leading to the independent evolutionary paths of bacteria and archaea.
Notably, the researchers found instances where bacteria and archaea independently evolved distinct enzymes capable of performing the same essential metabolic tasks. This parallel evolution may have been vital in reducing their reliance on hydrothermal vent chemistry, allowing both lineages to thrive as independent cells.
Energy sources for early metabolism also posed a significant question. Modern cells primarily depend on ATP for energy, but ATP is a complex molecule produced with the aid of enzymes. The researchers investigated potential energy sources that could have existed before ATP-based metabolism. They identified palladium, a metal found in hydrothermal vents, as a possible catalyst for metabolic phosphorylation reactions involving phosphite, a naturally occurring form of phosphorus.
The study represents the first comprehensive analysis of the full metabolic reaction network, encompassing 420 interconnected reactions. The researchers developed a method to arrange these reactions from the simplest to the most complex, potentially reflecting the sequence in which they emerged during early biological evolution.
Ultimately, the findings suggest that while there may be one ancient genetic code, the bacterial and archaeal lineages transitioned to independent cellular life separately. This research not only addresses profound questions about the origins of life but also highlights the complexity of early metabolic processes and their implications for understanding life's beginnings on Earth.




