Costa Rica's Health Outcomes Challenge Income Inequality Assumptions
A common assumption in discussions about health and income is that greater income inequality negatively impacts the health of the poorest citizens. However, recent findings from Costa Rica challenge this notion. According to the Gini index, a standard measure of income inequality, Costa Rica has a Gini score of 45.5 in 2025, indicating it is more unequal than the United States, which has a Gini score of 41.8 in 2024. Despite this, the mortality gap between socioeconomic groups is narrower in Costa Rica than in the U.S.
This intriguing finding stems from a 2016 study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) by researchers Luis Rosero-Bixby and William H. Dow. They analyzed census and death records from Costa Rica and compared them with U.S. data, ranking individuals by socioeconomic status based on education and income. The results were surprising: mortality rates in the U.S. were found to be 18% higher for adult men and 10% higher for middle-aged women compared to their counterparts in Costa Rica, despite the U.S. having significantly higher income and health expenditures.
The researchers noted that the disparity in mortality rates is particularly pronounced among the lowest socioeconomic quartile in the U.S., which experiences significantly worse health outcomes than those in Costa Rica's lowest quartile. This evidence suggests that the health inequalities observed in the U.S. are not an inevitable consequence of income disparities.
While the study highlights the role of lifestyle factors, such as higher rates of smoking and obesity in the U.S., it also points to the importance of access to healthcare. Costa Rica's national health system, known as the Caja, provides broad health coverage, which may help mitigate the effects of socioeconomic status on health outcomes.
However, the authors caution that their findings do not provide a complete explanation for why Costa Rica's socioeconomic mortality gradient is less steep. They emphasize that education and income may reflect other underlying factors that affect health, and that the relationship between income inequality and health is more complex than previously thought.
This study serves as a reminder that health disparities are influenced by a multitude of factors, and that simplistic interpretations of income inequality may overlook critical elements that contribute to health outcomes. It challenges the notion that reducing income inequality is the sole solution to improving health for disadvantaged populations and suggests that further research is needed to fully understand these dynamics.




