Study Suggests Bananas May Diminish Nutritional Benefits of Blueberries in Smoothies
Recent conversations have surfaced about the role of bananas in smoothies, particularly concerning their potential to diminish the health benefits of other ingredients, such as blueberries. A viral video featuring Dr. Rhonda Patrick, a biomedical scientist, has sparked debate by suggesting that bananas, a common smoothie ingredient, could reduce the absorption of beneficial nutrients from berries. According to Patrick, bananas contain polyphenol oxidase (PPO), an enzyme that can break down polyphenols, which are known for their positive effects on gut, heart, and brain health. This enzyme is also responsible for the browning of cut fruit.
In her appearance on the "Mel Robbins Podcast," Patrick demonstrated her smoothie-making technique, opting to exclude bananas. She cited a 2023 study published in the journal Food & Function, which examined how different smoothies affected nutrient absorption in eight healthy men. Participants consumed either a banana smoothie, a mixed berry smoothie, or flavan-3-ol capsules with milk on separate days. The results indicated that the banana smoothie led to an 84% lower peak concentration of polyphenols compared to the flavan-3-ol capsules, suggesting that bananas might hinder the benefits of polyphenol-rich foods like blueberries.
Despite these findings, registered dietitian nutritionist Ilana Muhlstein emphasized that the study's scope was limited, involving only eight participants and not specifically testing a banana-blueberry smoothie. She reassured that bananas still provide fiber and other essential nutrients. In response to the backlash from her initial comments, Patrick clarified that while bananas do affect polyphenol levels, they remain a nutritious choice and should not be entirely eliminated from diets. She suggested that those aiming to maximize polyphenol intake might consider alternatives like avocado, frozen zucchini, or Greek yogurt in their smoothies.
Nutritionists like Robin DeCicco have echoed these sentiments, stating that the advice regarding bananas is nuanced and should not be applied universally. The focus should instead be on increasing overall fruit and vegetable consumption, as many Americans currently consume too many processed foods. DeCicco pointed out that nutrition should be personalized, with recommendations varying based on individual dietary habits and health goals. Therefore, those looking to optimize their smoothies for polyphenol content might explore various ingredient substitutions while still enjoying the health benefits of bananas.




