Dietitians Weigh In on the Risks and Benefits of Fasted Workouts
Fasted workouts have become a trending topic on social media, with many praising their potential health benefits, including enhanced fat burning and weight loss. However, dietitians urge caution, noting that the evidence supporting these claims is not robust. Joy Bauer, a registered dietitian and contributor to TODAY, explains that while exercising on an empty stomach may increase fat burning during the session, this does not necessarily translate to greater fat loss over time. She states, 'Fasted exercise does seem to increase fat burning during the workout itself. When you haven’t eaten, insulin levels are lower, and your body is more likely to tap into stored fat for fuel. But here’s the important distinction: Burning more fat during one workout does not necessarily mean you’ll lose more body fat over time.'
Natalie Rizzo, another dietitian and TODAY nutrition editor, concurs, emphasizing that there is little evidence to suggest that fasted workouts lead to greater weight loss compared to exercising after eating, provided that total calorie intake and exercise levels are similar. In fact, consuming food prior to exercise may provide the energy needed to burn more calories and build muscle.
The dietitians also caution against blindly following fitness trends promoted by influencers, as some may pose health risks. Bauer notes that while there can be metabolic benefits associated with fasted exercise, such as improved insulin sensitivity, the most significant factors for effective weight management remain the overall quality of one’s diet, caloric intake, and consistent exercise habits.
When considering whether to eat before a workout, Rizzo suggests evaluating several factors: the type of workout, the timing, and personal feelings. For instance, if someone is engaging in light activities like walking or gentle yoga in the morning and feels fine without eating, it may be acceptable to exercise in a fasted state. Conversely, for more intense workouts such as weightlifting, high-intensity interval training (HIIT), or endurance sports, consuming carbohydrates beforehand is advisable.
Bauer likens fueling for a workout to preparing for a road trip, stating, 'If you’re taking a quick spin around the block, you probably don’t need a full tank of gas, but if you’re headed out on a long haul, you don’t want to start on empty.'
However, fasted workouts can be dangerous for certain individuals. Bauer advises paying close attention to how one feels during exercise. While some discomfort is normal, symptoms such as dizziness, lightheadedness, or inability to control one’s body are warning signs. If these occur, she recommends taking a break and consuming 15-20 grams of fast-acting carbohydrates, like juice or fruit, and allowing time to recover before resuming exercise.
In summary, while fasted workouts may offer some benefits, they are not universally suitable for everyone, and individuals should consider their unique circumstances and listen to their bodies.




