Study Reveals Environmental Costs of Proposed U.S. Dietary Guidelines
The 2025-2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans, which are set to be updated soon, may lead to increased greenhouse gas emissions, land use, and fertilizer use compared to the current Mean American Diet, according to a study conducted by researchers from Israeli and American institutions. Published in the journal PNAS, the study modeled the environmental consequences of the proposed dietary changes, focusing on greenhouse gas emissions, freshwater use, land use, and nitrogen fertilizer use.
Tamar Makov, a researcher from the Management Department and the School of Sustainability and Climate Change at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev (BGU), noted, "Surprisingly, we found that eliminating ultra-processed foods could reduce environmental impacts. However, the recommendation to increase and even double portion consumption could increase impacts substantially if protein comes from animal sources." This highlights a critical tension between health recommendations and environmental sustainability.
The study involved collaboration among several researchers, including Alon Shepon from Tel Aviv University, Gidon Eshel from Bard College, and David L. Katz from Diet ID, a private company. The Dietary Guidelines for Americans play a significant role in shaping U.S. food policy, influencing various programs from school meals to military food services, making the implications of these guidelines particularly impactful.
The researchers specifically examined two key recommendations: the reduction of ultra-processed foods and the increase in protein intake. They found that while eliminating ultra-processed foods could yield substantial environmental benefits, these advantages could be negated by the environmental costs associated with increased protein consumption, especially from animal sources. Their analysis indicated that adherence to the new guidelines could potentially increase greenhouse gas emissions, land use, and nitrogen fertilizer use by as much as 32% compared to the savings achieved by removing ultra-processed foods. Interestingly, water use was found to decline by 7% to 19% relative to the current diet, which is a positive outcome.
Makov emphasized that the average American already consumes sufficient protein, stating, "Eating even more protein, especially from animal sources, would needlessly add environmental burdens." The researchers advocate for revising the guidelines to prioritize plant-based foods over animal-based proteins to enhance environmental integrity, public health, and food affordability in the U.S.
The findings suggest that merely reducing ultra-processed foods may not significantly improve the environmental performance of American diets if these foods are replaced primarily with animal-based proteins. The researchers conclude that a dual approach of reducing both ultra-processed and animal-source foods while promoting plant-based alternatives could substantially lessen environmental impacts while supporting public health and food affordability.




